Canada Waterproofers vs Select Restoration Services: which one for water damage?
Canada Waterproofers and Select Restoration Services both show up as strong options for water damage restoration in the the team Toronto Area, but they solve different halves of the problem. Based on our methodology, this compares how each handles the actual water damage job: getting to the source, managing insurance, and getting a property dry and repaired.
Verdict
The right call here comes down to what stage of the problem you're in, not which score is higher. If water is actively getting into the property through a foundation crack, failing drain, or dead sump pump, Canada Waterproofers is built to stop that at the source. If the water has already done damage and you're now dealing with drying, repairs, and an insurance company, Select Restoration Services' claims advocacy and after-hours reachability make it the better fit.
Which should you pick?
Pick Canada Waterproofers if
- The problem is a leaking foundation, failed drain, or sump pump that needs a lasting structural fix
- You want a contractor with a long local track record and a history of honoring follow-up work years later
- You need the job diagnosed and completed in a single day with full site cleanup
Pick Select Restoration Services if
- You're filing an insurance claim and want someone to handle the negotiation directly
- The damage isn't purely water related, or you need someone reachable evenings and weekends
- You're coordinating repairs remotely, such as for an out-of-country property owner
The differences that matter
- Fixing the source vs. the damage. Canada Waterproofers is built around stopping water at the source (basement waterproofing, drain repair, backwater valves, sump pumps), while Select Restoration Services is set up to handle the aftermath across water, fire, and mold damage.
- Insurance claim support. Select Restoration Services' reviewers repeatedly point to direct insurance company negotiation and advocacy, a service not mentioned in Canada Waterproofers' feedback.
- Reachability. Select Restoration Services is described as answering evenings and weekends with same-day quotes, while Canada Waterproofers is praised for showing up fast and finishing most jobs in a single day.
- Track record size. Canada Waterproofers has built a larger review base (324 vs. 139) and edges out a slightly higher composite score, reflecting a longer local history of waterproofing-specific jobs.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Canada Waterproofers: 5 (324 reviews)
- Select Restoration Services: 5 (139 reviews)
- Services
- Canada Waterproofers: 24 7 emergency response, flood water extraction, water damage restoration service
- Select Restoration Services: 24 7 emergency response, fire smoke restoration, flood water extraction, mold remediation
- Core specialty
- Canada Waterproofers: Basement waterproofing, drain repair, backwater valve installation, sump pumps
- Select Restoration Services: Water, fire, and mold damage restoration plus insurance coordination
- Insurance claim handling
- Canada Waterproofers: Not mentioned in feedback
- Select Restoration Services: Directly negotiates and advocates with insurers on the homeowner's behalf
- Best fit for
- Canada Waterproofers: Structural water intrusion that needs a permanent fix at the source
- Select Restoration Services: Active water damage cleanup tied to an insurance claim, or damage spanning fire/mold too
- Verification
- Canada Waterproofers: Google-verified
- Select Restoration Services: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Canada Waterproofers: 94
- Select Restoration Services: 93
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Canada Waterproofers
Every recent review reports the same experience: crews arrive promptly, identify problems accurately, explain the work clearly, and complete jobs in a single day with immaculate cleanup. Reviewers highlight fair pricing, responsiveness years later for follow-up service, and professional crew behaviour on site. Staff document work with photos, compact soil after backfill, and even replant landscaping-details that set them apart.
The business handles basement waterproofing, drain repair, backwater valve installation, and sump pump service across the Greater Toronto Area. Repeat customers and referrals dominate the feedback; one reviewer notes staff returned six years after the original install to fix an unrelated drain issue without charging.
Select Restoration Services
Every call to Select Restoration gets an immediate callback from the team. Reviewers across water damage, fire, mold, and basement flood jobs consistently note how he identifies issues others miss, walks through options with patience, and handles insurance negotiations so homeowners don't have to.
Work runs clean and on time. From laundry leaks to full fire damage, the team stays professional under pressure. Multiple reviewers mention he coordinates repairs even for out-of-country clients, provides transparent quotes same-day (even late into evening), and answers questions evenings and weekends. One crew finished better than the original flooring that was no longer available.
Can't decide between options?
Give the details once and receive quotes from suitable water damage restoration service in Ontario.
Enquiries submitted through our forms may be passed to partner providers who can carry out the work. We may receive a referral fee for these introductions, but our rankings and scores are based solely on our published methodology and are not affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which one handles insurance claims for water damage?
- Select Restoration Services is the one reviewers credit with directly negotiating and advocating with insurance companies on the homeowner's behalf.
- Which company is better if the water damage is caused by a foundation or drain problem?
- Canada Waterproofers specializes in basement waterproofing, drain repair, backwater valves, and sump pumps, aimed at fixing the source rather than just restoring the damage.
- Does either company handle damage beyond water, like fire or mold?
- Select Restoration Services' reviewers describe work across water, fire, and mold damage jobs, while Canada Waterproofers' feedback centers on waterproofing and drainage work.
- Which has the larger track record?
- Canada Waterproofers has 324 reviews versus 139 for Select Restoration Services, and carries a slightly higher composite score.